Decision Aid Effectiveness

Patient decision aids are tools that help guide patients through the medical decision making process. It is important to study the effectiveness of implementing decision aids in the clinical setting. Research examines the role that these decision support tools play in making a medical decision with their health care provider.

Our Library

Below you will find samples of our most recent acquisitions in Decision Aid Effectiveness, grouped by resource type.

Shared Decision Making to Improve Care and Reduce Costs

A sleeper provision of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) encourages greater use of shared decision making in health care. For many health situations in which there's not one clearly superior course of treatment, shared decision making can ensure that medical care better aligns with patients' preferences and values. One way to implement this approach is by using patient decision aids -- written materials, videos, or interactive electronic presentations designed to inform patients and their families about care options; each option's outcomes, including benefits and possible side effects; the health care team's skills; and costs. Shared decision making has the potential to provide numerous benefits for patients, clinicians, and the health care system, including increased patient knowledge, less anxiety over the care process, improved health outcomes, reductions in unwarranted variation in care and costs, and great alignment of care with patients' values.…  Continue reading
Posted in Cost, Decision Aid Effectiveness, Health Care Policy, Patient Decision Aids, Patient Preferences, SDM Implementation | Tagged ACA, CMS, Cochrane Collaborative, decision aids, Group Health, health care costs, HHS, IOM, IPDAS, Medicare, NEJM, PCORI, practice variation, shared decision making Permalink

Introducing Decision Aids at Group Health was Linked to Sharply Lower Hip and Knee Surgery Rates and Costs

An observational study reporting the changes in surgical rates and costs in the first eighteen months following the start of a program to introduce decision aids for hip and knee osteoarthritis in the Group Health system. They found a 38% reduction in knee surgeries and a 26% reduction in hip surgeries; findings consistent with results from randomized studies of decision aids.…  Continue reading
Posted in Cost, Decision Aid Effectiveness, Patient Decision Aids, SDM Implementation | Tagged arthritis, David Arterburn, decision aids, Group Health, Health Affairs, health care cost, hip osteoarthritis, informed decision, knee osteoarthritis, surgery Permalink

Shared Decision Making: Informing and Involving Patients to Do the Right Thing in Health Care

The author discusses the concept of preference-sensitive decisions, that is, decisions where multiple reasonable options exist, and how a shared decision making process is critical to addressing this specific area of medical decisions. The article also looks at patient decision aids and how these educational tools can complement shared decision making by making the practice of high-quality medical care both more effective and more efficient. Lastly, the author discusses the role of shared decision making in state and federal policy and how this legislation can assist in making shared decision making a routine practice in medical care.…  Continue reading
Posted in Decision Aid Effectiveness, Health Care Policy, Patient Decision Aids, SDM Implementation | Tagged decision aids, health care, health care policy makers, preference-sensitive decisions, shared decision making, shared decision making implementation Permalink

Patient Decision Aids in Knee Replacement Surgery

This article discusses the use of patient decision aids in routine clinical practice for patients considering knee replacement surgery. The decision surrounding a diagnosis of knee osteoarthritis is an example of a preference-sensitive decision, meaning there is more than one viable option. Unfortunately, when patients are not fully informed, they are often unsatisfied with the outcome due to unrealistic expectations and a lack of understanding of the potential benefits and harms. The authors describe how implementation of patient decision aids, to support a shared decision making process, may address these issues and improve patient satisfaction, specifically in the context of knee replacement surgery.…  Continue reading
Posted in Decision Aid Effectiveness, Patient Satisfaction, SDM Implementation | Tagged Angela Coulter, arthroplasty, decision aids, knee replacement surgery, shared decision making Permalink

Helping Pregnant Women Make Better Decisions: A Systematic Review of the Benefits of Patient Decision Aids in Obstetrics

Objectives: Patient decision aids can be used to support pregnant women engaging in shared decisions, but little is known about their effects in obstetrics. The authors aimed to evaluate the effects of patient decision aids designed for pregnant women on clinical and psychosocial outcomes. Conclusions: Patient decision aids have the potential to improve obstetric care. However, currently the evidence base is limited by the small number of studies, the quality of the studies and because they involved heterogeneous decision aids, patient groups and outcomes.…  Continue reading
Posted in Decision Aid Effectiveness, Patient Decision Aids, Patient Involvement, Patient Preferences, SDM in Maternity Care, Special Populations | Tagged BMJ, decision aids, decision support, decision-making, evidence-based medicine, external cephalic version, labour analgesia, obstetrics, pregnancy, pregnant women, shared decision making, women Permalink

Decision Aids for People Facing Health Treatment or Screening Decisions

This is the most comprehensive review article that examines evidence of patient decision aids from numerous randomized control trials and provides a strong evidence base for the positive benefits of patient decision aids. The review finds that when patients use decision aids they: a) improve their knowledge of the options b) have more accurate expectations of possible benefits and harms c) reach choices that are more consistent with their informed values and d) participate more in decision making.…  Continue reading
Posted in Decision Aid Effectiveness | Tagged Cochrane Review, decision aids, Michael J. Barry, shared decision making Permalink

Use of Video to Facilitate End-of-Life Discussions with Patients with Cancer

This article describes a study that found that patients with cancer who viewed a video of various goals-of-care options, in addition to a verbal description were more likely to prefer comfort measures and avoid CPR. The study found that these patients were also more knowledgeable regarding advanced care treatment options and felt more certain about their decision compared to patients only hearing a verbal narrative. This article differs from some other studies regarding decision aids since other uses of video decision support tools have focused on helping people make treatment or screening decisions, whereas this video was used to initiate end-of-life discussions.…  Continue reading
Posted in Decision Aid Effectiveness | Tagged cancer, decision aids, end of life, Michael J. Barry, shared decision making Permalink

Using Interactive Videos in General Practice to Inform Patients about Treatment Choices: A Pilot Study

Our objective was to assess the acceptability of using an interactive video system in a general practice setting to inform patients about treatment choices. A descriptive cohort study was carried out in eight general practices in Oxfordshire. Fifty-four patients with mild hypertension and 29 with benign prostatic hypertrophy were studied. Patients' views of the video, treatment preference, level of involvement in treatment decision and satisfaction with decision-making process and GP's views of the effect of the video on subsequent consultations were measured.…  Continue reading
Posted in Decision Aid Components, Decision Aid Effectiveness, Patient Decision Aids, Patient Involvement, SDM Implementation | Tagged Angela Coulter, benign prostatic hypertrophy, decision-making, general practice, informed decisions, informed patients, interactive videos, patients, treatment decisions, UK Permalink